Create account

GUIDE · CONVENTIONAL VS SHEAR SPINNING

Shear spinning vs conventional spinning: shear forming and the sine law

Conventional spinning and shear spinning both form a flat blank on a rotating mandrel, but they treat the wall thickness in opposite ways. This guide compares the two methods side by side (blank diameter, wall thickness, passes, forces, machines and tooling), explains the sine law with a worked example and shows when to choose each method or combine both on one part.

Last updated: · KSOTech Engineering Solutions

What is conventional spinning, and what is shear spinning?

Conventional spinning is multi-pass spinning that lays a flat blank onto the mandrel step by step. The roller makes a series of forward and, where needed, back passes, each moving the sheet a little closer to the mandrel. The material flows radially inwards and the wall thickness stays roughly equal to the blank thickness. Because the surface area is roughly preserved, the blank must be noticeably larger than the finished part.

Shear spinning, also called shear forming or power spinning, works differently. The roller presses the material against the mandrel at a controlled gap, usually in a single pass per region, and deliberately thins the wall. Each element of the blank keeps its distance from the axis and shifts parallel to the axis onto the mandrel. The unformed flange stays flat, and the blank diameter is close to the largest diameter of the part.

In short: conventional spinning changes the diameter and keeps the thickness; shear spinning keeps the diameter and changes the thickness. Most other differences follow from this.

Conventional spinningShear spinningBlankCupt ≈ t₀D₀ > dBlankt = t₀ · sin αConeαD₀ ≈ d_max
From blank to part: in conventional spinning a large blank becomes a smaller-diameter cup of the same thickness; in shear spinning the blank diameter is kept and the wall is thinned. Schematic, not to scale.

Shear spinning vs conventional spinning at a glance

The table summarises typical, textbook-level differences. Real behaviour depends on material, thickness, machine, roller and mandrel; use it for orientation, not as a specification.

Conventional vs shear spinning: typical differences
AspectConventional spinningShear spinning
Blank diameterNoticeably larger than the part; estimated from the surface areaRoughly equal to the largest part diameter
Wall thicknessStays close to the blank thickness (local thinning is unwanted)Deliberately reduced; on cones t = t₀ · sin α
Number of passesMany forward (and often back) passesUsually one pass per region, sometimes a few stages
Material flowRadially inwards; the flange is compressed around its circumferenceParallel to the axis; the unformed flange stays flat
Forming forcesComparatively low; spread over many passesHigh; they grow with the amount of thinning
Machine and rigidityManual and lighter CNC spinning lathes can be enoughA rigid, powerful CNC machine with stable roller guidance
Mandrel and toolingFollows the inner shape; simple (even hardwood) mandrels are common for prototypesHard mandrel that matches the final inner contour exactly
Typical partsCylindrical and deep cups, domes, lamp shades, tank headsCones, funnels, reflectors, nose cones and other conical or curved shells

The sine law: t = t₀ · sin α

For a cone shear spun from a flat blank, the ideal wall thickness follows from simple geometry. If every element of the blank moves only parallel to the axis, its thickness measured along the axis stays t₀. On a wall inclined at the half-cone angle α, the thickness perpendicular to the wall is therefore:

t = t₀ · sin α

t₀: blank thickness · t: wall thickness · α: half-cone angle (between wall and axis)

AxisMandrelαBlank (t₀)shift parallel to axist = t₀ · sin α
The sine law: each element of the blank shifts parallel to the axis; the thickness along the axis stays t₀ and the thickness normal to the wall becomes t = t₀ · sin α. Schematic, not to scale.
  • Worked example: a 3 mm blank is shear spun into a cone with a half-cone angle of 30°. Since sin 30° = 0.5, the ideal wall is 3 × 0.5 = 1.5 mm, half the blank thickness.
  • With the same blank, a 45° cone gives about 2.1 mm and a 60° cone about 2.6 mm. The steeper the cone (the smaller α), the thinner the wall.
  • The law also works backwards: for a 1.5 mm wall on a 30° cone, choose a 1.5 ÷ 0.5 = 3 mm blank. The wall loses 1 − sin α of the blank thickness, a quick measure of how demanding a shape is.

These numbers only illustrate the formula; the real thickness depends on material, machine, roller and set-up. Measure the first part.

Limits of the sine law

The sine law is an ideal model: it assumes pure axial shifting, a perfectly rigid machine and a mandrel the material follows exactly. It is a starting point, not a guarantee.

  • It applies directly to cones. On curved profiles such as domes and reflectors α changes along the profile, so the wall thickness changes too unless the blank or preform thickness varies.
  • Small half-cone angles mean large reductions. A material can only take a limited reduction per pass before cracking, so very steep cones are usually made in stages, sometimes with intermediate annealing.
  • If the roller gap is set clearly tighter (over-reduction) or wider (under-reduction) than the sine law suggests, the material flows unevenly: the flange can bend or wrinkle, or the risk of wall cracking rises. That is why the gap is set by measuring the first part.
  • Machine deflection, springback, roller geometry and feed all move the real thickness away from the ideal value.

Blank diameter for each method

For conventional spinning the first estimate assumes constant surface area: the blank area equals the area of the part's mid-surface. For a flat-bottomed cylindrical cup (diameter d, height h) this simplifies to the formula below; add a trim allowance for the edge.

For shear spinning the blank diameter is roughly the largest part diameter, because material does not move radially. The thickness changes, so the area rule does not apply; the general principle behind both methods is constant volume.

Conventional: D₀ = √(4A / π) · cup: D₀ ≈ √(d² + 4·d·h)

Shear (cone from a flat blank): D₀ ≈ d_max

Shear spinning vs flow forming (tube spinning)

Flow forming, also called tube spinning, is often confused with shear spinning because both thin the wall with rollers. But flow forming starts from a tube or a thick-walled cup-shaped preform, not a flat blank. The rollers reduce the wall and the part grows longer along the mandrel, which fixes the inside diameter.

There is no sine law here: the roller-to-mandrel gap and the reduction per pass set the wall thickness. Typical products are tubes, cylinders, housings and rims; shear spinning makes cones and curved shells from a flat disc. KSOTech CAM does not cover flow forming.

When to choose conventional spinning, when to choose shear spinning

As a rule of thumb, the shape of the part and its wall-thickness requirement decide:

  • Conventional spinning: cylindrical or deep parts, walls that must stay close to the blank thickness, prototypes and small batches, or when only a manual or lighter CNC spinning lathe is available.
  • Shear spinning: cones and gently curved shells, when a thinner, lighter wall is acceptable or wanted, when a smaller blank saves material, and when a rigid machine and an exact, hard mandrel are available.
  • Shear spinning work-hardens the wall and usually gives a smooth surface and consistent thickness.
  • Very steep cones (small α), very thin target walls or materials with low ductility point towards several stages, a conventional preform or a different process.

Combining both methods on one part

Many parts are not purely one or the other. A common approach is conventional preforming followed by shear sections: a cylindrical or flanged region is spun conventionally and a conical region is shear spun to the target thickness. The order can also be reversed.

Plan such a part region by region: decide where the wall must keep the blank thickness and where it may be thinned, check that the blank estimate covers both, and keep transitions smooth so the roller does not mark or overload the wall.

Common mistakes

  • Sizing a shear-spun part with the conventional area formula (the blank comes out far too large), or the reverse.
  • Setting the roller gap without reference to the sine law, which leads to flange bending, wrinkling or cracking.
  • Applying one half-cone angle to a curved profile and expecting a uniform wall.
  • Asking for too much reduction in one pass on a steep cone instead of planning stages.
  • Using a mandrel that does not match the final inner contour; in shear spinning the mandrel defines the inside.
  • Underestimating the forces: a machine or mandrel that deflects produces a thicker, uneven wall.
  • Using the nominal sheet thickness instead of the measured one; any deviation in t₀ carries straight into the wall.

How metal spinning CAM helps

A CAM system does not replace process knowledge, but it makes decisions visible and repeatable: working from a DXF profile, you see which regions are spun conventionally and which are shear spun, and review the passes before the machine moves.

In KSOTech Metal Spinning CNC CAM you can define where shear spinning applies and switch individual regions on or off; conventional passes are used where a region is switched off. The passes are checked in a toolpath simulation (not a forming simulation) and exported as G-code for your control. As with any program, the output must be verified on the machine before production.

This guide gives general, textbook-level information. Angles, thicknesses and examples are illustrative; real values depend on material, machine, tooling and process conditions. Validate every new part with a trial run supervised by a qualified specialist.